March 12, 2025
.png)
American consumers have long been the backbone of economic resilience, using credit cards and personal loans to sustain spending through uncertain times. However, with recession fears resurfacing, the concern now is whether they’ve reached their financial limits.
The Credit Crunch: A Warning Sign for the Economy
The stock market has recently experienced broad declines, with consumer lending companies hit particularly hard. Major lenders like American Express, Capital One Financial, Discover Financial, and Synchrony Financial saw significant drops, with an average decrease of around 12% in 2025, compared to a 4.5% dip in the S&P 500. This decline may signal growing unease about consumer debt levels and the potential impact on the overall economy.
Historically, consumer lenders have been early indicators of financial distress. Surges in late payments and charge-offs (loans written off as losses) have previously led to stock sell-offs. While recent spikes in delinquency rates have often been isolated to borrowers who took on substantial new debt in 2021 and 2022, current trends suggest broader financial strain.
Rising Debt and Economic Uncertainty
Recent data from WalletHub reveals that the average household’s credit card debt surpassed $10,000 in late 2024—an inflation-adjusted milestone not seen since 2009. Meanwhile, investors are increasingly anxious about recession risks, particularly with uncertainty surrounding new trade policies and government spending strategies. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent’s remarks about the need for an economic “detox period” have only fueled concerns.
The key determinant for lenders is employment stability. As long as people remain employed, they can generally manage their debt payments. However, job losses, particularly in sectors dependent on imports or government funding, could disrupt this balance. If economic stress mounts, consumers may shift their repayment priorities, favoring mortgages over credit card and auto loan payments, which could negatively impact lenders.
Market Volatility, Tariffs, and Federal Reserve Policy
Market volatility has increased in response to ongoing concerns about economic policy. The stock market has been sensitive to shifts in trade tariffs, with President Trump’s administration implementing new import duties that are expected to disrupt supply chains and increase costs for businesses and consumers. This, in turn, could lead to reduced spending and corporate earnings pressure.
Additionally, the Federal Reserve’s interest rate policies remain a critical factor in shaping economic stability. After a series of rate hikes in 2023 and 2024 aimed at controlling inflation, the Fed has signaled a cautious approach moving forward. However, continued high interest rates mean consumers are facing higher borrowing costs on mortgages, auto loans, and credit cards, further straining household finances.
Higher-Income Households Show Signs of Strain
One of the most alarming trends is rising delinquency rates among high-income earners. Data from CreditGauge shows that from January 2023 to January 2025, the rate of consumers earning $150,000 or more who are 60 to 89 days behind on payments has more than doubled. Although their delinquency rate remains low at 0.16%, the sharp increase suggests growing financial stress, even among those who typically have more disposable income. Higher-income consumers drive significant discretionary spending. If they cut back, it could trigger broader economic contraction.
The Balancing Act: Will Consumers Keep Spending?
Despite these concerns, American households still have financial cushions. As of late 2024, household debt-service payments were approximately 11% of disposable income, remaining below pre-pandemic norms. However, sentiment plays a crucial role in consumer behavior. A recent Federal Reserve survey found that Americans estimate a 14.6% chance of missing a minimum debt payment in the next three months—the highest level since April 2020.
If financial confidence declines, consumer spending could retreat rapidly, affecting everything from retail to travel and entertainment. The performance of major consumer lenders will be a crucial economic barometer in the coming months.
What This Means for You
As a financial advisor, I encourage clients to take proactive steps to strengthen their financial stability. Here are a few key strategies:
- Monitor and Manage Debt: Ensure that your debt levels remain manageable relative to your income. Avoid excessive credit card balances and high-interest loans.
- Build Emergency Savings: Having a financial cushion can help weather economic downturns without resorting to debt.
- Review Investment and Spending Habits: Economic uncertainty underscores the importance of a well-diversified investment portfolio and prudent spending decisions.
- Plan for the Unexpected: Working with a financial advisor can help you create a resilient financial plan that adjusts to changing economic conditions.
The coming months will reveal whether consumers can sustain their role as the economy’s stabilizing force or if financial stress will lead to a broader slowdown. If you're concerned about how these trends impact your personal finances, let’s talk about strategies to safeguard your financial future.